Justice

Domain:

Team: 
Project 7

General informations
=======================
Login for testing:
BN : Matrikelnummer + Role
PW : Matrikelnummer
Sample
1126277ELS - Einlaufstelle
1126277KZL - Kanzlei
1126277JUD - Richter
1126277ATD - Attendee
1126277ADM - Administrator

- Each document/task gets a new id after any activity (e.g. Claim task/sign verdict etc.). That means that IDs are NOT court file numbers, but system generated number.
- If you would like to operate from two (or more) roles simultaneously, then you must use two separate browsers (which share no cookies). In that way, you will see that when 1 task is finished (by one role), the next task immediately gets a notification (another role).
- If you would like to use just 1 browser window, then make sure that after logging-out (from one role) and logging in (to another role) you refresh your browser. Or go to address: http://marioluef.space:8080/# to refresh the page.
- If a button appears disabled after you have entered something in a text field, then you should press “tab” (or change focus from text field) to make the button enabled.
- To search a court file, you have to know the court number. If the number exists, the button will automatically enabled.
- To see the BPMN use this link to get a deeper knowledge about the process https://drive.google.com/open?id=0B2bbGjarjgA3b0ZQS0hieTF1MVE

STEP 1 - Einlaufstelle
=======================
- If you would like to see existing court files then click on “Court files” and enter existing court file number. The result is either an error (if court file not found) or a detailed information about a specific court file
- If you click on “Incoming documents” then you get an upload form, where you can manually upload a file to the system. After uploading there are two possibilities:
-- A file can be recognized by OCR algorithm and it will be assigned automatically if there is anywhere in the document a court file number in the format: “case number: CG/XXXX”, where “XXXX” stands for court case number.
-- If uploaded file cannot be automatically recognized, then it can be done manually. A new task in the list of “Current tasks” will be created with the option “Claim task”. When you press “Claim task”, then the task is assigned to you and you can click on “find court file by reading through the document”. Then you will see the uploaded document where you can look for a court file number. There are two options after that:
--- If you have found the number, then you press “Yes” in the dialog box and input case number manually. After pressing “Assign document” your task as “einlaufstelle” is finished.
--- If you have not found the number, then you press “No” in the dialog box and you have to create a new court file. After you input a new case number in the text field you will have to press “Assign document” and after that your task as “einlaufstelle” is finished.
- After you have assigned the document it will disappear from the “Current tasks” list, meaning your task is done and the next step can begin.

STEP 2 - Kanzlei
=======================
- After logging in, you see a “Current tasks” list
- If you have completed step 1, then you should see at least 1 task where you can click “Claim task”
- After you claim a task, you can click on “Classification of the document within the court file”
- Then you see a document that was by default classified as “Eingang”
- You can now change its classification to any other category from the drop down list
- After choosing an appropriate classification and clicking on “Classify document”, the new classification is saved
- Your “Current tasks” list should not contain that file anymore and you can proceed to step 3

STEP 3 - Richter
=======================
- After logging in you see “Current tasks” list with a new item “Read new document”, which you can claim
- After claiming this task, you can press “Read new document”
- You will see an uploaded file and a dialog box whether a classification is correct. There are two options then:
-- If you press “No”, then the document goes back to “Kanzlei” (step 2). You will no longer see this file in the “Current tasks” list
-- If you press “Yes”, then you have the option to add a new “Note” and/or new “Order”. In any case, you have to press “Decide classification”.
-- If you have chosen either of the options (add note/order), then you will get a text box for note and/or order where you can put note/order text and save them
- After that you see a dialog box “Reference file preparation” where you can decide if “you need this document in your reference file” and if “you want to schedule a trial date”.
-- If you choose “Yes” to the first option then you have to input an existing case number where this file will be added.
-- If you choose “Yes” to the second option then a text field comes where you can set a date and time when the trial will start. #### ATTENTION ## If you choose a date in the future, you have to wait till this date! This means, that you block the process chain and couldn't attend step 4 ##### After you have chosen a date and time you can press “Schedule trial”
- If you have started a trial, then you can create a new verdict for this case. That means that the trial has finished and you as a judge (“Richter”) have passed a verdict
- When a verdict has been passed you as a judge (“Richter”) has to sign it. To do that you have to press “Sign verdict”
- After you have signed a verdict, step 3 is finished

STEP 4 - Teilnehmer
=======================
- After logging in you see “Current tasks” list with a new item “Sign verdict atd”, which you can claim
- When you have claimed the task, you see a court file, containing all relevant court case files.
- You can now press “Sign verdict” to sign a verdict
- After you have signed a verdict, you will no longer see it in your “Current tasks” list. Step 4 is finished. The file will go back to the judge.

STEP 5 - Richter
=======================
- After logging in you see a new item “File court file” in your task list
- After claiming this task you see a dialog box saying if you want to close the court file
- You can now close the court file by pressing “File court file” button
- Court file is now marked as “closed” and you can see its details in the detailed view. Go to “Court files” and search with your court file number (CG/X).
- In the section “Important Dates” you can make sure that “Court file date” is set, meaning it has been closed

Year: 
2017-01-01T00:00:00

Comments

Step1 & 2 works fine, but step 3 doesn't show anything

Hey, thanks for testing. There could be more than one reasons. First off all, ist that each user could access to your files, you uploaded or process startet. e.g. if one suggest to start with "Kanzlei" and you are finished with Step 1, the other user has his notice that he had tasks (your task) so he could finish it. The result is, that you don't see anything in your task list. This is the main reason i guess ... The other think is to refresh your browser after you logged in or try to click to "court files" to get another view and then click to "justice" to get to your task list.

Hello, so i tested it yet with your account and you've been right. We will look the failure and give feedback as soon as possible. Edit: I've found the problem! Please do it again, but be in the past EVERYWHERE! So at the step "Start Trial" please select a Date in the past e.g. a month ago ... otherwise, you have to wait till the date is actual! After that you could start "create a verdict" after this you could start "Step 4" ATD.

Seems to work!

Hey thanks for testing!

I can ping it

Hey, sorry but what do mean with that?

Hi, your process is very detailed, your effort is visible and the process is highly sophisticated compared to the other processes around here. I followed your process step by step until step 4 and did not take note of the case number as a result I could not finish it. The ui needs some love (case number recommendation or a list of all cases assigned to me) as the system becomes useless if you dont remember the case or document number. TL;DR A high sophisticated process with some flaws. Best, Nico

In common, you don't need the case number for your testing. In fact there are several independend tester all around, you could pick any taks shown in your task list. Perhaps if you're test on a special time, where you are alone, you could finish all with your uploaded file.

Hi Gerald, thank you for your response. There are no tasks in my tasklist in step #4 - how may I finish my process if I cannot find any tasks? Best, Nico

Step 1 works fine, only thing to consider would be to not allow non-pdf files to be uploaded. I uploaded a .txt file and it's stuck in my current tasks now and is unable to be processed. Step 2 & 3 works as intended, step 4 doesnt show any task, which is why my process stopped here.

Please see my comment on https://wfm.ec.tuwien.ac.at/comment/225#comment-225. I will test it again and let you know if anything not works.

Worked pretty good, but i could not start step 4

Please see my comment on https://wfm.ec.tuwien.ac.at/comment/225#comment-225. I will test it again and let you know if anything not works.

worked good for me

Works fine until step 4. When logging in as attendee, no tasks are listed

Please see my comment on https://wfm.ec.tuwien.ac.at/comment/225#comment-225. I will test it again and let you know if anything not works.

Works fine.

Hey thanks for testing!

Very nice application good job, but just some feedbacks: 1. sometimes after refresh you get an error as "This application has no explicit mapping for /error, so you are seeing this as a fallback." 2. In step 3, how can the judge see what classification was given to the document in step 2? I can only accept or reject if the document is correctly classified but I cannot see the classification. 3. I cannot see trial date and court file date after the document is uploaded (even if the judge puts a trial date I still can't see it when I open the court file)

Hey thanks for testing. The issue about the fallback error is known. We assume nobody refresh his page (cause he don't need this, perhaps only after login). For the classification you have to know the court number, so you could search for it in "court files" section. At this section you have the detail information about this court case. The court file date, would be saved after the judge has closed the court file. This could be viewed at the "court files" with the exact court number e.g. CG/77. In the real world, the document you upload, has the court number in it. So you would see it after click on a task in your Task List. To try it please prepare a PDF with the court number and then upload it and walk through the process with them.

cool app no warning or message when you as a judge want to create a verdict with empty description

Hey thanks for your testing. This is a very abstract view on a trial process. I don't know the legal to it, but in some cases a judge don't need to write something, to create a verdict, perhaps cause it's just right.

To search a court file, you have to know the court number. If the number exists, the button *did not * automatically enabled. But after changing the tabs in the browser or pressing the tab. It worked. Really nice example.

Hey thanks for testing. yes you're right, so in a brut-force session you could figure out the case numbers. Otherwise you'll get an Exception or Error Message.
Josef Glas's picture

Could not login? 8606876ELS - Einlaufstelle 8606876

Thanks for reply, we would look at your number! I've tried it yet and it works. Please try it again! BN: 8606876ELS PW: 8606876
Josef Glas's picture

Hello Gerald, Thank you. Now login is working. I could upload a pdf and perform the steps 1 to 4 successfully. The process is working fine, great. Performance could be be better, but waiting 5-10 seconds for each action is acceptable for me. Congratulations. Regards, Josef

What do i do if i (as Judge) added a Note and Order but didnt sign? i dont seem to be able to re-edit or re-assign the file to me again as a Judge.

Yes of course, if your started this you won't be able to edit this. It wasn't modeled to reedit something. We only modeled the high abstraction of the whole process, we don't go in detail. But in real case it would be able to edit everything until it is signed.

I got to step 3, but i checked no on both fields at the end. In Step 4 there are no Files unter Current tasks. Also i couldnt navigate past page 1 in the Courtfile browser.

Hello Philipp, could i ask you which Date you take for your trial? As i mentioned in the description, if you choose a date in the future e.g. 01.07.17 then you have to wait until this date arrive. This means you couldn't get to step 4. Cause the end of Step 3 would be to sign a verdict to get a task in Step 4. It is independent if you check add order/note. So now i got your situation, if you don't choose "start trial" you won't be able to get to this document anymore. This means the process is ended now for this court case.
Serdar Seringec's picture

one of 3 projects which are complex AND working here. well done i would say, it needs a bit time to check it, but it looks good and i see the great effort in it.

Serdar S.

Hey thanks for testing!

everything worked fine! great job! (I tested it with the registration credentials of a college)

Hey thanks for testing! I tried your login with your account, and its seems to work.

Everything works fine. Complex but very well described process. Overall probably the best implemented project

Hey thanks for testing!

Everything works!

Hey thanks for testing!

Worked good for me

Hey thanks for testing!

Everything works fine.

Hey thanks for testing!

it worked fine

Hey thanks for testing!

for me as well and I finally remember my student number ;)

The process is a complex one, but it worked flawless for me, the documentation is helpful and the system is easy to use.

Hey thanks for testing!

Difficult to test because of five different logins. Standard tests have been successful and it is the most complex one. Logic from begin to end is thought effectively.

Pages